Which dog should we use in our logo? Please tell us

After all the feedback about the poor sheep being scary - we've decided to:

1. Use a dog - after all the dog is the star of the show in a sheepdog game
2. Draw two different dogs (a bit fluffier and cartoon like) and let people pick

The first image shows the dogs on their own:

The second shows how the current game logo might look with a dog instead of the (now scary) sheep:

Please comment on Facebook or against this post and let us know which you prefer.